Autistic teenager ‘failed by agencies’

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on twitter

Autistic teenager ‘failed by agencies’

Last month the deputy coroner for West Yorkshire, Professor Paul Marks, announced the outcome of an inquest into the death of Gareth Oates. Gareth died on March 2nd 2010, less than a month after his 18th birthday. He threw himself under a train at Marsden Station.

  • You can read about the case  HERE.

‘There was a global failure in his assessment, management and access to specialist services, amounting to neglect,’
Coroner Prof Paul Marks

This was a desperately sad case. Gareth was a high-functioning autistic young man. The coroner was aware that a number of state agencies had been involved in Gareth’s care, so he decided to hold a full inquiry into the cause of death under Article 2 of the European Court of Human Rights.

A coroner’s role is limited by law to answering four factual questions:

  • who the deceased was;
  • where he died;
  • when; and
  • how he came by his death.

A coroner may not make findings of civil or criminal liability.

Gareth had a diagnosis of autism when he was very young. He had a statement of special educational needs. At 11 years, he began to express suicidal thoughts. He had considerable support at school, and managed to weather some stormy periods. In 2008, aged 16, he went to a college of further education. He found the transition difficult, because the 25-hour a week one-to-one support which he had at school was withdrawn.

Gareth experienced bullying from local youths, sometimes on his way to college and sometimes at college. In July 2009, after college had broken up, he went to some cliffs in Sheringham, Norfolk, with the intention of throwing himself off. He left his mother a voicemail to say he was committing suicide, and a suicide note. He then changed his mind. The police detained him under the Mental Health Act 1983, section 136. A hospital psychiatrist and a social worker concluded that he was not suitable for admission for hospital.

Thereafter, Gareth and his mother experienced great difficulty trying to access any services. The family was repeatedly told that there was a gap in services for people like Gareth. Unfortunately, it seems that this is an all too common problem for young people with autistic spectrum disorder. Eventually, he was able to access specialist counselling.

Early in 2010, Gareth started expressing suicidal thoughts again, and was assessed by a community mental health team. They referred him to a psychiatrist. Gareth committed suicide the day after he saw the psychiatrist, who could find no signs of mental illness.

The coroner heard evidence from mental health experts and the author of a serious case review commissioned by Suffolk County Council. He accepted evidence that there was a number of failings in Gareth’s psychiatric management amounting to ‘gross failure’. In particular, he accepted evidence that:

  • Autism has a high co-morbidity rate with other mental health disorders, which can occur in 40% of cases;
  • Pharmacological treatment for psychiatric co-morbidity was not pursued, when it should have been;
  • ‘Talking therapies’ were inadequate;
  • There were failures in communication between the agencies caring for Gareth;
  • No comprehensive longitudinal assessment of his autism took place;
  • No consideration was given to the possibility of him having any psychiatric co-morbidity;
  • There were gaps in service provision, with no specialist service for people like Gareth, and a hiatus between child and adult services for those aged 16-18;
  • There was a lamentable lack of a named expert in autism to take charge of his care and adopt a holist approach to his needs;
  • There was no satisfactory transition plan to ease Gareth’s move to college.

Recording a narrative verdict of suicide, the coroner said that the failings amounted to ‘neglect’. In his view, on the balance of probabilities, either detention under the Mental Health Act or treatment with drugs would have averted Gareth’s death. He noted that the Autism Act 2009 ironically came into force in 2010. He expressed his intention to write (under the Coroners’ Rules, rule 43) to the Secretary of State for Health and to the Royal College of Psychiatrists about the gap in psychiatric services for 16-18 year olds and to Suffolk County Council for a report on its progress in implementing its obligations under the Autism Act 2009. It is to be hoped that the Coroner’s report will help to improve services for young people like Gareth nationally.

23 responses to “Autistic teenager ‘failed by agencies’”

  1. […] http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newid_3130000/newsid/_313200/3132058.stmPowered by Yahoo! AnswersWilliam asks…Is it possible to see the early signs of mental illness in children?My son is 8, and … it possible to see the early signs of mental illness in children?My son is 8, and i'm worried about […]

  2. […] abuse and mental disorders as a result i could maybe help a bit? Im 18?xPowered by Yahoo! AnswersHelen asks…Can someone please help me find a good newspaper article on mental health?It needs to b… someone please help me find a good newspaper article on mental health?It needs to be recent as in […]

  3. […] research on comprehensive asthma manage-ment into practice have proliferated. … Retrieve Document Health Education & BehaviorHttp://heb.sagepub.com Health Education & Behavior DOI: 10.1177/…esearch images" […]

  4. […] County Suzanne K Saville DDS MPH CDR USPHS, Ruth Wetta-Hall RN PhD MPH MSN, … Read Content Kids Asthma Screening Quiz – Does Your Child Have Symptoms Of …Asthma and Physical Education – Pa…>Kids Asthma Screening Quiz – Does Your Child Have Symptoms Of …Asthma and Physical Education – […]

  5. […] will receive state voucher money to attend religious schools. What will they learn? … Read News Building Asthma Education A BOUT A STHMA E DUCATION – This …177 Building Asthma Education ABOUT A…s photos" […]

  6. […] (1920, C.E.A. Winslow). It is concerned with threats to health based on … Read Article T HE DIFFERENCE – LEADING THE WAY TO HEALTHIER COMMUNITIES …Grant Award: $20,670 Pediatric Asthma…tle="Asthma Education Rural Communities" […]

  7. […] include Spanish-language pediatric asthma guidelines, environmental history … Doc Retrieval Summary Of The 2007 NAEPP GuidelinesAsthma Control Test (in Spanish and English) Asthma action plan…ma Education Spanish photos" […]

  8. […] , NY 10029 212-423-8162 Manhattan 10am-2pm Metropolitan Hospital Center/First … Doc Retrieval Strategies For Improving Asthma Outcomes: A Case-Based Review …Strategies for Improving Asthma Ou…tion 2010" […]

  9. […] including asthma, eyesight or hearing problems, mental health issues, or recent … Read Article Nursing Management For Asthma Education In School Aged ChildrenMicrosoft PowerPoint – Nursing Manag…tent/plugins/content-revenge/images/pdf.png" alt="PDF file" title="PDF file" /> Nursing Management […]

  10. […] need for asthma education among health professionals. The program will help those who … Fetch Doc Analysis Of Assembly Bill 264-Amended: Pediatric Asthma Self …Pediatric asthma education and trai…s of Asthma Education Training" title="pictures of Asthma Education Training" […]

  11. […] Education and Prevention Program. NAEPP School Asthma Education Subcommittee … Get Content Here TEACHING PLAN – READING ABOUT ASTHMAHow might the students imagine bridging the gap between these t…="Asthma Education Plan photos" title="Asthma Education Plan photos" […]

  12. […] clinical immunology. The AAAAI also produces numerous public education materials. … Read Article YouTube – Broadcast Yourself.And you have the privilege of a decent education I know all about phot…font-weight:bold; text-transform:capitalize;">YouTube – Broadcast Yourself.And you have the […]

  13. […] Epilepsy – Rottweiler Love That Max; Allergy Moms; Special Education Law Blog … Read Article Exhaled Nitric Oxide 1Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE W…cation Arizona" title="Asthma Education Arizona" […]

  14. […] providers and caregivers; 98% of surveyed participants reported learning something … Fetch Doc Student Asthma Record¾ Asthma education provided for all school staff ¾ Asthma education offered …text-transform:capitalize;">Student Asthma Record¾ Asthma education provided for all school staff […]

  15. […] for physical education teachers and coaches should incorporate a few key points … Access Document TV Watching Causes Asthma, Or Vice Versa?When I was in elementary school, teachers used to yell at …ins/content-revenge/images/about.png" alt="About" title="About" /> TV Watching Causes Asthma, Or […]

  16. […] visits. 10-14 In the United States and Canada, successful asthma management programs … Read Here Healthy Debate And The Autism CommunityEverything – from causes, treatments and the desirability of…/> Healthy Debate And The Autism CommunityEverything – from causes, treatments and the desirability […]

  17. […] on a daily basis and corticosteroid medciation during severe exacerbations. … Access Content Asthma Stories: Kim C. From Detroit, MI – YouTube3:21 Watch Later Error Nora opening Pocoyo and Pep…lize;">Asthma Stories: Kim C. From Detroit, MI – YouTube3:21 Watch Later Error Nora opening Pocoyo […]

  18. […] of managing asthma are some of the factors that command unified teamwork. … View This Document ASTHMA PREVALENCE, BARRIERS TO EFFECTIVE TREATMENT,The reasons for this are multiple and complex, b…ion Lack photos" […]

  19. […] From the Beginning, Being Sick Isn't Fun, Checkups Are Important, Help for Asthma … Read Article Fighting Influenza – BiologyFlu and Asthma – Treatments for the Flu and Asthma Homework Help/Lesson…m:capitalize;">Fighting Influenza – BiologyFlu and Asthma – Treatments for the Flu and Asthma […]

  20. […] Economic Value Of Home-Based, Multi-Trigger, Multicomponent …The National Asthma Education and Prevention Program (NAEPP) guidelines 21,22,60 dis-tinguishfour classes of asthma severity: mild intermittent al. Effectiveness of home-based, multi-trigger, multicomponent interventions with an environmental focus for reducing asthma morbidity: a Community Guide … Fetch This Document Teacher's Guide: Asthma (Grades 3 To 5)How are allergies and asthma related? 1. 2. 3. Teacher's G…/a> […]

Related Posts