A former sub-postmaster who was jailed after unexplained accounting losses at his Post Office branch has had his theft conviction referred to the Court of Appeal, amid new evidence that Capture software could generate false shortfalls.
Narinder Aujla, 61, was convicted of five counts of theft in 1998 after an audit found a £10,000 shortfall at the Caledonia Post Office in Dudley, where he worked as sub-postmaster between June 1991 and April 1998. He was sentenced to four months in prison.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) said there was a real possibility the Court of Appeal would find that prosecuting Aujla had been an abuse of process and quash his conviction.
Capture was an accounting system used by the Post Office before the introduction of Horizon. Aujla began noticing discrepancies in his branch’s balance sheets about a year after Capture was installed, but could not identify what had caused them.
When the losses were small, he used his own money to balance the books. As they grew, he could no longer afford to do so. The Post Office helpline advised him to ‘roll the losses over’ to the following week, but the shortfall continued to increase.
Following an audit in autumn 1996, Aujla was told his branch had a £10,000 deficit. He was interviewed about the losses and said he did not know what had caused them.
After his conviction, the Post Office pursued him for the money. He eventually repaid the £10,000 in instalments. He has never appealed against his conviction.
Concerns about Capture emerged during the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry. The government subsequently commissioned an independent investigation by Kroll Associates UK Ltd, which found a reasonable likelihood that the software could generate accounting shortfalls for sub-postmasters.
A separate report by computing consultancy MFC Partnership, commissioned on behalf of sub-postmaster Patricia Owen in 1997, identified software faults that would not necessarily have been apparent to users. The CCRC referred Owen’s theft convictions to the Court of Appeal in October 2025, citing concerns that her prosecution had been an abuse of process.
Aural applied to the CCRC in June 2025 after learning of concerns about Capture. The commission said its decision to refer his case was based on the Kroll and MFC reports, together with new evidence in his witness statement.
Dame Vera Baird KC, chair of the CCRC, said this was the third Capture-related conviction the commission had referred to the appeal court. She said the cases added to evidence that earlier Post Office accounting systems, like Horizon, may have generated false losses that were blamed on sub-postmasters.
The CCRC said it had received 40 applications relating to pre-Horizon convictions. Of these, 21 had been rejected, four referred to the Court of Appeal, one found to be a Horizon case, and two withdrawn. A further 12 are under review. Four applications relating to Horizon convictions are also being reviewed.