Assault and ‘use of force’ complaints against prison staff are going uninvestigated due to a lack of evidence, including in some cases a total absence of CCTV or body-worn camera footage. In half of inspections by the prisons ombudsman, the poor use of body-worn cameras by staff has been identified as an issue, which is against prison policy in England and Wales.
New research released last week by the Prisons Ombudsman has identified procedural failings in complaint handling by prisons in over half of the 143 complaints analysed, and where investigators requested CCTV, it was not provided in 64% of the cases they looked into.
They said on the whole prison staffing faces issues with ‘professionalism, poor internal investigations into conduct and poor complaint handling’.
The body’s special bulletin highlights that a lack of evidence was a key concern for the Ombudsman and ‘significantly restricted’ its investigations. Poor quality and lack of evidence provided by prisons impacted 36% of the cases analysed.
Body-worn camera footage was often not retained, not started, was of poor quality or had been turned off. In a case study highlighting the issue, Mr A made a complaint that he was assaulted by staff, but no body-worn camera was activated during the incident. The investigation found that the evidence from the staff member was contradictory on whether force was needed. The Ombudsman found that the prison’s inability to provide recordings was ‘unacceptable and unprofessional and, at worst, suspicious’.
A second case study in the bulletin involved a vulnerable prisoner under two-hour observations who made a complaint about an assault. The officer’s body-worn camera was accidentally switched on and off three times. The footage captured the prisoner saying “let go of my arm”, although officers denied touching him.
The investigator said full body-worn camera footage would have provided a ‘far better understanding’ of the incident. The bulletin calls for recordings to be retained in line with policy and provided to the investigators where requested.
The bulletin also raised concerns about the quality of internal investigations by prisons. It found that in 29% of complaints reviewed, there was no evidence that the prison spoke to staff members about the complaint. In 9% of cases analysed for the bulletin where there was a formal internal investigation, the staff member complained about was also part of conducting the investigation.
The bulletin features a complaint submitted by the Howard League for Penal Reform on behalf of a 19-year-old prisoner (Mr D). The incident arose during a strip search and resulted in significant damage to his teeth and an allegation of a racial slur being used by prison staff. A body-worn video camera (BWVC) was turned on mid-restraint.
The footage was difficult to see as the lens was frequently obscured. Audio footage captured an officer saying to Mr D: “How f***ing difficult was that mate. You stupid, stupid boy.” It was also found that a referral to the equalities team to investigate any racial discrimination had not been made. The Ombudsman investigation found that the actions of prison staff ‘did not reflect the standards of professionalism expected from prison staff’.
The Howard League for Penal Reform responded to the Ombudsman’s Bulletin by saying that most people ‘have little idea of what really goes on’. Andrea Coomber, Chief Executive of the Howard League, said that ‘this is why it is so important that contentious incidents are recorded properly and the ombudsman is provided with all the evidence needed to conduct thorough investigations’.
The Prisons and Probation Ombudsman, Adrian Usher, said in the bulletin that ‘there must be greater consequences for staff and prisons for such failures’.