Lawyer of your choice

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on twitter

Lawyer of your choice

barbed wire -  Terry FreemanThere are proposals to limit the advice given to persons arrested in the police station to a duty solicitor, as opposed to allowing them to request their own solicitor.

I cannot see a single good reason for this proposal – it won’t save money, the solicitor attending will be paid (presumably) for each client he sees, in the same way as an ‘own’ solicitor would. It will cause delays though, and it will potentially cause miscarriages of justice.

As a police station representative I would act for clients that would ask for me directly as they were regular clients of my own firm. I would also be on a rolling rota to act as a duty solicitor for people who did not know, or could not nominate a solicitor to act for them. On those occasions I could have as many as 10 clients waiting on my advice. If it did get busy I would call upon my two colleagues to help out, prioritising those I felt needed to be seen more quickly, such as children, or those with mental health issues. Not everyone would be willing or able to give away the fees like that in a client’s best interest.

Acting regularly for clients I came to know them very well. I knew of their partners, their children – they asked after mine. I knew those who had ADHD, health issues, fears, and phobias. One lad with OCD couldn’t eat anything he hadn’t prepared himself and so would go hungry. Another had been so badly sexually abused he couldn’t bear to be touched to be searched – leading to the potential for high risk situations, both for him and the officers. I knew the parents of kids – they came to trust and rely upon me to look after their children in custody. I would often agree to go to represent them even if I was off duty – I knew they relied on me and I wouldn’t let them down.

I also knew those who were highly likely to be guilty of the crimes they were accused of (although I never assumed anything). I could get those people to see sense – they trusted me not to bullshit them – I could work out some sort of deal whereby they, the police, the system was happy.

Not all, I wouldn’t be so naive to claim it, but many solicitors working in the police station don’t just see their clients as a fee. Trust me, the money I earned for turning out night after night, for however long it took to deal with the case, doesn’t make up for the lost sleep, the lack of a social life, and the family disruption. We do it because we care about people, innocent or guilty.

If you can see the potential for the need for a person to be able to call upon a solicitor they know, and trust, to assist them whilst they’re interviewed and detained, in sometimes extremely distressing circumstances, please consider signing this petition HERE.

3 responses to “Lawyer of your choice”

  1. […] of criminal defendants to choose their solicitor from a list of those providing legal aid (covered HERE). This doesn’t just fly into the face of the government mantra about competition and choice (see […]

  2. Bill Ryan says:

    I have never had to deal with this part of a criminal case but i know that most clients I represent value their solicitor and the advice.

    This trust element will be lost and there will be many more random pleas and unwarranted trials as there will be a lack of early guidance. This is very important.

    So I can predict more guilty pleas that are not warranted and more trials when there should not have been trials. So all in all there is a “lose lose” situation in the offing.

    People will get longer sentences than they would have and innocent people will be convicted. There will be no savings in government expenditure and when the likes of G4S and Stobart find they are losing money the government will bail them out as they have just done with Capita.

  3. The reason for the loss of choice is to save money by getting big contractors to bid based on exclusive contracts, AIUI. They can only get Capita et al to give cheap bids if they can guarantee volumes of work, so the contracts are to be exclusive. This also means local solicitors won’t be on rotas unless they work through the big contractor, and they’ll most likely be paid less for it – if the contractor even allows local solicitors to sign up.

Related Posts