WE ARE A MAGAZINE ABOUT LAW AND JUSTICE | AND THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO
November 20 2026
WE ARE A MAGAZINE ABOUT LAW AND JUSTICE | AND THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO

Doctor who gave evidence against Letby was barred from treating patients

Doctor who gave evidence against Letby was barred from treating patients

Pic: Andy Aitchison. HMP Bronzefield - where Lucy Letby is serving 15 life sentences

A doctor whose evidence helped convict Lucy Letby had been barred from treating patients over safety concerns while her trial was under way, but the jury and defence were not told, an investigation by The Guardian has revealed.

Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a paediatric hormone specialist, gave evidence for the prosecution that two babies had been poisoned with insulin. His testimony supported the allegation that Letby had injected insulin into intravenous fluid bags.

According to David Conn and Felicity Lawrence of The Guardian, documents show that University College London Hospitals NHS foundation trust (UCLH), where Hindmarsh worked, excluded him from clinical duties in March 2023. The trust had told the General Medical Council (GMC) that it could not accept the level of risk he appeared to pose to children and young people.

The concerns included advice Hindmarsh had given to child patients about insulin. In one case, a child developed diabetic ketoacidosis, a potentially life-threatening condition caused by a severe lack of insulin.

Hindmarsh had been presented to the jury as a leading authority on insulin. The prosecution described him as the ‘pre-eminent expert’ in the field.

The GMC had opened an investigation into Hindmarsh in November 2022, the same day he first gave evidence for the prosecution. A medical tribunal subsequently imposed restrictions on his work and required him to practise under supervision. In April 2023, after UCLH had barred him from clinical duties, the tribunal declined to suspend his medical registration.

The hospital’s decision and the tribunal’s restrictions were not disclosed to Letby’s defence team. The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said it had not been informed of either development and therefore had not disclosed them.

Letby’s barrister, Mark McDonald, said Hindmarsh’s evidence had been ‘pivotal to the prosecution’s case’. ‘The insulin allegations were not simply another part of the prosecution’s case; they were its cornerstone, presented as scientific proof that she had deliberately poisoned babies and was capable of murder,’ he said.

McDonald added: ‘If the foundations of the insulin cases are unsafe, the consequences for the safety of the wider convictions cannot be overstated.’

The defence has submitted reports from seven experts to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), challenging Hindmarsh’s interpretation of the medical evidence. The experts dispute the diagnosis of insulin poisoning and raise concerns about the blood tests relied on by the prosecution.

Letby, a former neonatal nurse at the Countess of Chester hospital, was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others. She was sentenced to 15 whole-life terms. Her appeals have been rejected and her case is now being considered by the CCRC. AS the Guardian report notes failures of disclosure are recognised as ‘potential grounds for a referral to the CCRC… and for convictions to be overturned’.

The CPS said: ‘The CPS met all its disclosure obligations and no objections were raised by the defence at any stage in relation to expert evidence relied on by the prosecution.’ Hindmarsh declined to comment. The GMC investigation ended in November 2024 after he asked to remove himself from the medical register. There was no final finding on the allegations.